Sheriff Rebecca West is still dealing with the fallout from the yacht club’s demise when two new mysteries arise. A teenage girl’s body is found at the cemetery covered in occult symbols, and beside her, a partially dug-up corpse is found that isn’t supposed to be there.
Rebecca must interrogate the girl’s friends and uncover the truth of what happened, all the while getting stonewalled by teenagers who insist the old witch is responsible.
Meanwhile, Deputy Hoyt Frost investigates the mysterious corpse and discovers that the yacht club may have had more skeletons in their closet than he could have imagined.